Wednesday, June 30, 1999

Top drug-cop's property attached

The National Directorate of Public Prosecutions on Wednesday attached property belonging to the former head of the Durban narcotics bureau. Directorate spokesman Sipho Ngwema said the property of Superintendent Piet Meyer was impounded in terms of a provision of the Organised Crime Act. The unit is said to have removed three truck loads of goods from Meyer's house in Umkomaas, south of Durban. Ngwema said Meyer was under investigation on charges of theft, fraud, defeating the ends of justice and racketeering.

Meyer was being investigated in connection with the distribution of R200 000 in forged old bank notes and R10 000 stolen from a safe while he was head of the narcotics bureau.The theft was not reported. He is also being investigated in connection with running a casino. It was also alleged he received R10 000 a month as protection money from illegal casino owners to prevent their operations being shut down.

The head of the assets and forfeiture unit of the directorate, Willie Hofmeyer, said Meyer's expenditure for the past two-and-a-half years came to nearly half a million rand, while his salary was R155000 per annum. The unit attached his 4-wheel drive vehicle, lounge suite, refrigerator and stove, and he was given 14 days to go to court to convince it that he did not receive this property through illegal means.

In a statement, provincial police commissioner Chris Serfontein said the investigation was started by his office in December 1997. "The case was investigated by the South African Police Service for nine to ten months whereafter Bululani Ngcuka was appointed and the Directorate of Public Prosecutions established," Serfontein said.

Source: IoL

Pretoria fraud suspect gets bail

In what could become one of the biggest fraud cases in South Africa, a Pretoria businessman who has allegedly defrauded unsuspecting investors of at least R49,5-million, has appeared in the Pretoria Magistrate's Court on charges of transgressing the Banking Act. Johannes Gerhardus Grobler (32), of Amandasig, was arrested early Tuesday morning at his offices in Akasia Medical Centre. He has been released on R100 000 bail.

People who have put money into Emus Property Investment should contact the investigating officer, Captain Hugo Wolmarans, at (012) 329-6860.Grobler is due to appear in court again on October 4.

Source: IoL

Tuesday, June 29, 1999

Mpapele appears in court on corruption

South African Local Government Association financial manager Carol Mpapele appeared briefly in the Pretoria Magistrate's Court on two charges of corruption and was released on bail of R15 000, police said.

Inspector Gideon Thessner said the charges related to an alleged request by Mpapele to contractors supplying computers to the association to inflate their invoices so he could pocket the difference.

He was still being held at the Pretoria Central police cells late on Tuesday following his failure to come up with the bail posted. He will appear in court again on August 13.

Source: IoL

Hammer murderer gets life sentence

Imposing a life sentence for the "callous and cowardly" August 1998 murder of Rosetta farm manager Simon Buntting, who was bludgeoned to death with a hammer, a high court judge said it was a sad reflection on the criminal justice system that the killer and his companion were released on parole a month before the incident. Justice McCall and two assessors convicted Kenneth Gcaleka, 24, of murder and robbery with aggravating circumstances for bludgeoning Buntting, 66, four times on his head with a 4lb hammer after breaking into his farmhouse on August 24. His body was found lying under his duvet in his blood-soaked bed the following day. A life sentence for murder accompanied by robbery with aggravating circumstances is now mandatory in terms of the 1997 Criminal Law Amendment Act, unless a court finds there are compelling circumstances which require a lesser sentence. Judge McCall said on Tuesday that in the present case he found a life sentence to be "wholly appropriate". For the robbery, he sentenced Gcaleka to 15 years' imprisonment in terms of the same Act.

Gcaleka's brother, Themba Gcaleka, 21, who was found guilty only of theft of goods from Buntting's home, was jailed for five years. The younger man was not found guilty of the murder and robbery charges since there was no evidence to contradict his own testimony that he had not anticipated resistance, that he did not enter the bedroom where Buntting was killed and had not taken part in the assault, but instead had told his brother to stop "quarrelling" with Buntting.

Source: IoL

FBI-styled system nips hijackings

A clampdown on hijackers in Johannesburg is paying off as the US Federal Bureau of Investigation-styled anti-crime initiative takes effect. Launched in February by National Director of Public Prosecutions Bulelani Ngcuka, the initiative has seen a reduction in the number of hijackings and also speedier prosecutions.

The police anti-hijack unit and a prosecution task team have joined up to form a partnership, which in terms of the initiative, is intended to stamp out hijackings in Johannesburg. "Things seem to be working well, but it is difficult to put an exact figure on it as statistics fluctuate monthly, but the signs are positive," said Inspector Mark Reynolds, police spokesperson for Johannesburg.Annual hijacking figures in Johannesburg have shown a steady decrease since 1996 when 2 797 were reported to the city's 20 police stations. In 1997 the figure went down to 2 642 and dropped further last year to 2 493. While police are reluctant to claim "major successes at this early juncture", detectives are already experiencing a lighter docket load and are spending less time in court as their cases are processed faster through the criminal justice system.

Ngcuka's team has, in the past two months, broken hijacking syndicates operating in Sandton, Pretoria and Mozambique, and arrested 36 suspects, all of whom have been refused bail. The team has also recovered stolen vehicles valued at more than R3-million.

Justice Department spokesperson Simon Ngomane yesterday said investigators had been instrumental in "solving numerous murder cases connected to car hijacking". Since March 1 the Johannesburg anti-hijacking unit has passed every one of their cases onto the task force's special court operating at the Johannesburg Magistrate's Court. "In the past detectives would wait six to nine months for a conviction, and another three months before sentencing. This waiting period has been considerably decreased by the special court, which means that the detectives are closing dockets quicker and so spending less of their time in court on remands," said Reynolds.

A recent case concerned a hijacking in Sandringham, in north-eastern Johannesburg, on March 24. The perpetrator was found guilty on June 15 and sentenced to 15 years in jail. "This new approach has had a knock-on effect for detectives. It makes justice swifter, eases their docket load and frees them up to spend more time on investigations," Reynolds said.

Source: IoL

Unclaimed Mandrax worth R25m found

A random search of the Johannesburg International Airport customs warehouse afternoon led to the discovery of a large shipment of Mandrax tablets that had not been collected. The tablets have a street value of R25 million, and weigh 55kg.

Silvian Pillay, the director of customs at the airport, said the shipment of Mandrax tablets was flown into South Africa from Mumbai, India, in December. Marked with a fictitious name and address, the consignment was offloaded at Johannesburg International Airport.

The airline held the unclaimed parcel for 14 days before handing it over to customs, as it was legally obliged to do. "We come across drug shipments fairly regularly, although we usually locate them quickly because we receive tip-offs all the time," said Pillay. "This case was rare. We don't often have the stuff sitting here for six months, neither are the loads this big. This was an unusually large load as far as Mandrax goes."

Source: IoL

Executed women may take clues to grave

When 25-year-old Sheriza Singh and the man she claimed was her live-in lover, Gavin Wessels, are laid to rest this week, they may take with them the truth behind their gruesome murders and the apparently senseless killings of three other women in Kwadukuza (formerly Stanger), on the KwaZulu Natal north coast. Singh witnessed the shooting of Wessels at the Just Friends nightclub, apparently at the hands of her ex-boyfriend, early on Sunday.

Police say she claimed to be living with the popular IFP councillor and businessman, although she was too emotional to make an official statement at the time. She apparently then went home to her family farm."She was to have come in to make a statement yesterday," said Superintendent K Naidoo. However, on Sunday evening, four gunmen wearing balaclavas attacked the house. With single shots to the head, they executed Singh, her 73-year-old grandmother Sabkhree Singh, her mother Nirmala Singh (40), and a friend, Meriska Naiker (18). A relative, Vijen Singh (21), was seriously injured and is in a critical condition.

Wessels' brother Anton denied there had been any relationship between Sheriza and Gavin, saying his family did not know her at all. "He went to the nightclub alone, got into an argument and was shot at point-blank range. This was so unnecessary," he said. He said his brother, although estranged from his wife, had been in daily contact with her recently with a view to reconciling. Singh's family also could not shed any light on the incident.

A close friend commented that it was sheer speculation that the disco shooting and the farmhouse killings were linked. Police are also hesitant to connect the two incidents. "The only link is Sheriza, and while everything may point to a connection because she was at the club, it would be dangerous to say it for sure," said Naidoo. However, he said, the style of the farmhouse murders did not point to ordinary robbery.

A man arrested immediately after the shooting of Gavin Wessels will appear in court today.

Source: IoL

Monday, June 28, 1999

People dive for cover as men rob van

In Johannesburg shoppers at Fourways Crossing shopping centre were sent screaming and diving for cover on Monday when shooting erupted in the centre's parking lot as six armed men robbed a Fidelity Guards cash-in-transit van of an estimated R250 000. Bullet-riddled cars, damaged shop fronts and numerous chalk-circled shells bore graphic testimony to the heavy-calibre shootout which resulted in shrapnel penetrating a security guard's eye. The guard, Gerhardus Engelbrecht (39), also sustained a gunshot wound in the leg but not a single bystander was injured.

The robbery occurred shortly after 1pm. A group of armed men attacked a security guard carrying a case of money to an armoured Fidelity Guards van waiting in the parking lot."I reckon the guys with pistols were waiting in Pick 'n Pay, and charged at the guard as he walked out with the money," a witness said. "They grabbed him round the neck and held a gun to his head. And the poor guy just stayed calm. He slowly went down on the ground and let them take the money and his gun," the witness, who asked not to be named, said.

The robbers ran out of the Pick 'n Pay foyer area and joined their accomplices who were waiting in a white Colt bakkie. The robbers in the getaway vehicle, armed with AK-47 rifles, opened fire on the Fidelity Guards van and a Golf car, also white, that escorted the van. Shoppers and bystanders, frightened by the gunshots, panicked and scrambled for cover in shops.

Captain Lungelo Dlamini, police spokesperson for Johannesburg, said that the gang had fired mostly at the waiting guards and disarmed three of them. One of the guards in the escort car was injured and taken to Sunninghill Clinic for treatment. "As the gang fled the scene they fired random shots. Several cars in the parking lot were damaged by flying bullets," said Dlamini.

Police hastened to the scene and the suspects' bakkie was soon afterwards found abandoned about a kilometre away in Lonehill. Dlamini was unable to say how much money was stolen. The Brixton Murder and Robbery Unit is investigating. The robbery is the third shopping centre shootout in Johannesburg since April. The first occurred at Fourways Mall when armed men drove through the doors of the mall, rammed into the display window of a boutique, fired shots and escaped with clothing. In May a gang, using similar tactics, robbed a clothing store in Eastgate and fired at shopping centre guards before escaping.

Source: IoL

Heath unit to act against IBA officials

The Heath special investigative unit has decided to take legal action against former Independent Broadcasting Authority (IBA) officials in an effort to recover more than R200 000 in state funds. A probe by the Auditor-General in 1997 found three former councillors - Peter de Klerk, Lindall Shope-Mafole and Sibeletso Mokone-Malabane - had charged personal expenses to their business credit cards and claimed allowances to which they were not entitled. The three resigned their posts after accepting responsibility for a breakdown of financial and administrative controls at the IBA, but denied they were liable to reimburse the authority.

Heath unit spokesman Guy Rich said Section 5 notices - the equivalent of a summons - would be drafted and issued to "four or five ex-IBA officials" within a fortnight.He declined to name the officials, saying this could only be done once the notices had gone out. Rich said the unit had consulted the auditing firm Deloitte and Touche - which was instructed by the Public Protector in 1997 to investigate the controversy - and decided to institute legal action.

Those officials who received a Section 5 notice would be entitled to legal representation, and given 21 days to file a return notice to say whether they intended to defend the action against them. A pre-trial hearing would then be held, and a date set down for the matter to be heard by a special tribunal. The tribunal, a special court of law which has the power to hand down judgements for assets to be recovered, should sit before the end of September, Rich said. The money was outstanding for more than two years, he said.

In an audit report on the IBA for the year ended March 31, 1998, and tabled in Parliament on Monday, the Auditor-General said the body's financial statements fairly reflected its financial position, and there were significant improvements in its financial controls. The pay packages of serving IBA councillors had been reduced in November last year to bring them into line with salaries approved by the state expenditure department. The audit report noted that money owed by the three councillors was still outstanding.

Source: IoL

Panicked police just press the button

At least 10 police stations in the Cape Peninsula and Stellenbosch have been fitted with panic buttons linked to armed response security companies in the past few months. This protection has been installed at Claremont, Hout Bay, Stellenbosch, Table View, Sea Point, Maitland, Camps Bay, Simon's Town, Fish Hoek and Durbanville. Grassy Park police station is guarded by a private company. Sea Point police station has a closed-circuit television system that is monitored by a security firm.

Although the new security arrangements - provided free - embarrass police, they are not without benefit. Two Sundays ago, a policeman at Sea Point used a panic button to call for help after three alleged gang rapists overpowered him and snatched his gun. Luckily, he had removed the pistol's magazine before entering the alleged rapists' cell for a routine, early-morning inspection. The four police on duty at the time were soon joined by a patrol from an armed response company and the attackers were returned to their cell. Another security firm has a contract to post guards with the Flying Squad in Pinelands.

In Hout Bay, where police do not have a proper police station, residents recently launched a non-profit company, Blues Buddies, to finance a private police service. Police and armed response firms are also jointly monitoring emergency radio services as part of growing co-operation between private sector and police, who say they are understaffed and under-resourced. Provincial Community Safety Minister Mark Wiley has described the situation as a "most unsatisfactory practice" and he is asking Safety and Security Minister Steve Tshwete to visit the Western Cape to see for himself the impact of staff shortages and threats to police.

Coming after several daring raids on police stations and the bombing of some, the new security arrangements are meant to discourage criminal gangs and urban terrorists from seeing police stations as easy sources of weapons or cash. However, some of the police stations that are linked to security firms had their systems installed before high-profile attacks. This year, five policemen have been murdered - four of them on duty - in the Western Cape. Since the beginning of the year, there have been a number of attacks on Cape Town police.

- January 3: five armed, masked men strolled through a broken gate at Claremont police station at 3am, locked up police officers and escaped with weapons, radios and bulletproof vests.

- January 14: top Pagad investigator Benny Lategan was ambushed and killed on the R300.

- January 28: six people were injured when a bomb exploded outside the central police station at Caledon Square during lunch hour.

- February 19: Pagad investigator Schalk Visagie was shot and seriously wounded on the M5.

- March 9: a masked gang of seven grabbed 12 guns, ammunition and two radios in a raid on Stellenbosch police station in Bird Street.

- May 9: a car bomb exploded outside Athlone police station. Children in nearby backyards were hit by glass fragments.

- June 6: three armed men tied up a policeman at Harare police station in Khayelitsha and stole three guns and 18 rounds of ammunition.

Mr Wiley said: "It is a sad day in any country if the police must be reliant on the handouts of others to ensure their (own) safety."

Source: IoL

Maduna will sack drunken prosecutors

Justice Minister Penuel Maduna has warned that prosecutors who report for work drunk will be fired. Speaking on the SABC programme Newsmakers last night, Mr Maduna said his department had received reports about prosecutors in Mdantsane, near East London, reporting for work "not sober". "I must warn those who come to work drunk that they will be sacked."

Maduna said the department would investigate why courts worked such short hours - an average of four-and-a-half hours per day - which could be due to lengthy investigations and postponements due to weak evidence. After meeting with Bulelani Ngcuka, national director of public prosecutions, he said: "We expect monthly reports from his office on how prosecutors are performing their tasks."

Maduna denied the Government was failing to pay prosecutors adequately. He said the department had budgetary constraints.

Source; Iol

Tshwete's 'ruthless' anti-crime plan

The game's up - that was the message from Safety and Security Minister Steve Tshwete to criminals today as he spelled out to Parliament a "ruthless" crackdown on crime. The strategy hammered out includes roadblocks, cordoned-off areas and search operations. And there is a plan for an FBI-style agency to probe serious crime.

Tshwete said the past five years had been spent formulating strategies against crime and amalgamating various police forces inherited from the apartheid past. "What is required now is a ruthless implementation of that plan as a matter of urgency. We are ready, more than ever before, not just to send a message to criminals out there about our intentions, but more importantly to make them feel that 'die tyd vir speletjies in nou verby' (the time for play is over)," Tshwete said."In the process, ordinary law-abiding citizens might be inconvenienced and we would like to appeal to them to understand why we are stepping up this kind of action." He said the Government was adopting an inter-departmental approach to fighting crime.

The ministers of justice and constitutional development, safety and security, correctional services and home affairs would meet once a fortnight to draw up reports for the Cabinet on the progress of the battle and co-operate in investigating cases. This committee will involve the national Directorate of Public Prosecutions in the investigation of a crime and its successful presentation to the courts.

Tshwete said plans were under way to establish a structure to investigate priority crimes announced by President Thabo Mbeki during his address to Parliament last week. He said the structure would be similar to the FBI (Federal Bureau of Investigation) in the United States. He was confident they would be able to report to the president on this structure in less than two weeks. "The new structure will focus - with the back-up of highly skilled personnel, effective equipment, adequate resources - on crime intelligence-gathering, investigation and prosecution of persons and groups committing or involved in priority crimes," Tshwete said.

On Friday Mbeki listed such areas as Mitchell's Plain in Cape Town, Inanda in KwaZulu Natal and Katlehong in Gauteng as having the highest concentrations of crime in South Africa. He said multi-disciplinary intervention would be implemented to reduce the levels of crime in these areas. Tshwete told Parliament on Monday that such operations had already begun.

Source: IoL

Sunday, June 27, 1999

Minister goes to trial over illegal guns

Provincial Safety and Security Minister Nyanga Ngubane(55) appeared in a Pietermaritzburg regional court for the second time on Friday in connection with charges relating to the unlawful possession of arms.

Ngubane, Sgwili Ngubane(35) and IFP Midlands councillor Gamanthu Sithole(53) were charged following a pre-dawn police raid on the homes of Ngubane and Sithole in Bulwer on April 15. Ngubane's case was postponed to November 8 for trial.

Source: IoL

Friday, June 25, 1999

Mbeki makes crime his first priority

President Thabo Mbeki put crime at the top of his priority list on Friday, announcing an overhaul of the South African Police Service and a range of other measures aimed at improving the criminal justice system. In his state of the nation address to a joint sitting of the National Assembly and National Council of Provinces (NCOP), Mbeki said one of his government's main tasks would be to transform South Africa into "a winning nation" with the opportunity of "a better life for all". But "the impermissible level of crime and violence" was standing in the way of a better South Africa, he said. The government alone could not stem the tide of crime, Mbeki said.What was needed was "a mobilisation of the whole nation into united people's action, into partnership with the government for progressive change and a better life for all".

Mbeki's plans include the recruitment of "new recruits with the requisite levels of education" into the police, and a new human resources strategy to "fast track" these recruits into management levels. He also announced that a new multi-departmental unit would be established to deal with all national priority crimes, including corruption in the police. Legislation against money-laundering was in the pipeline, as well as new laws to "deal mercilessly with all crimes involving guns, including the illegal possession of firearms, killing of police officers, corruption in the criminal justice system and intimidation of witnesses".

Another inititative is the establishment of "special commercial crime courts" to deal with white-collar crime. Mbeki committed his presidency to "honest, transparent and accountable government" and said he was "determined to act against anybody who transgresses these norms". He said the growth, employment and redistribution programme (Gear) and the reconstruction and development programme would remain the cornerstones of economic policy, and promised a range of measures to deal with unemployment.

Mbeki said the government would continue discussions with all role players about issues affecting the job market, including labour legislation, in an effort to create the best conditions fro job creation. The government would remain committed to fiscal discipline, and continue its programme of restructuring state assets, Mbeki said. To promote badly-needed foreign investment, an International Investment Council would be established which will include "some of the leading players in the global economy" to make South Africa an attractive destination for investors.

Internationally, South Africa intended taking a more active role in regional conflict resolution. "We cannot accept that war (and) violent conflict are a permanent condition of existence for us as Africans... We will therefore contribute whatever we can towards the resolution of conflicts on our continent." Mbeki said the government was "preoccupied" with the issue of gold sales by central banks and and promised to maintain contact with all role players in an attempt to minimise the impact of gold sales on the local economy.

Source: IoL

Thursday, June 24, 1999

KZN warfare described to TRC

Any deaths of family members caught in violent clashes between the leaders of the ANC and the IFP in Shobashobane on the south coast in the early 1990s resulted in the counter-attacks that led to the high incidence of bloodshed in the area. This was the evidence of an amnesty applicant before the amnesty committee of the Truth and Reconciliation Commission (TRC) on Wednesday. The TRC also heard that the two political organisations "did not see eye to eye as to which one should operate in the area".

Ziphakamise Nyawose (30) told of how people closest to him were killed during the attacks, which made him flee the area to stay in the bush for three months."As a member of the ANC I was also a victim of these attacks. In 1991 I was attacked on three occasions at my home. In 1992 my house was attacked twice and I was also attacked at the taxi rank. In 1993 my brother Bongani was murdered and his decomposed body was found in the bush after a week. "In the same year I was in the company of Mandla Blose when we were attacked at a taxi rank. On that occasion we retaliated by shooting back at our attackers," he said.

Nyawose said he went to report the shooting to the police but was told that they would not investigate matters involving ANC supporters. "From there it was clear to us that the police were collaborating with our attackers. These attackers were known in our area. Their names were Mhlati Mbambo, Thokozani Blose, Dudu and Sithombe (Goodman) Ngcobo. They were all IFP members," he said.

Nyawose has applied for amnesty for the murder of Bhekabantu Samuel Cele and attempted murder of IFP strongman and businessman Goodman Ngcobo in 1993. Nyawose said Cele had died in the shoot-out but he was not the target; he was only caught in the crossfire. "Ngcobo was attacking us because some members of the ANC had killed his mother in 1990, but I was not involved in that killing," he said. He said he lost everything when his house was burned down by IFP supporters during the violence. He told the amnesty committee that he had since reconciled with Ngcobo.

Source: IoL

Wednesday, June 23, 1999

Businessmen kidnapping scheme cracked

A top-level team of detectives arrested members of an international fraud syndicate which has been linked to the kidnapping of several prominent businessmen, one of whom was found murdered this month. The detectives made their breakthrough when they arrested five alleged kidnappers early on Tuesday, several hours after rescuing a Jordanian national the kidnappers had lured to South Africa with the promise of making a quick fortune.

Seven cases of kidnapping, resulting in 10 arrests, are being investigated by the police task team, drawn from the SAPS National Special Investigations Unit and formally established two weeks ago. Four of the victims were international businessmen who had been lured to South Africa by criminals using either a Nigerian advance-fee fraud or the "black dollar" scams. Police, who have been tight-lipped about investigations despite having released several warnings about the scams internationally in the past few days, confirmed major breakthroughs in their investigations. Inspector Mark Reynolds, a spokesperson for the team, said more than one syndicate was believed to be behind the kidnappings.

The most recent breakthrough occurred during the early hours of yesterday when three Nigerians, a Ghanaian national and a South African suspect were arrested in connection with the kidnapping of Jordanian citizen Abu Baker Mohammed Ali Saqaallah,57. Saqaallah was lured to South Africa by a fraud syndicate on June 12 and kidnapped at Johannesburg International Airport on his arrival. His attackers contacted his family in Jordan and demanded about R240 000 for his release.

The task team found Saqaallah, unharmed, on Monday afternoon and freed him. Continued work led to the five arrests on Tuesday. Four arrests have also been made in connection with the kidnapping of Johannesburg businessman Lawrie Butler, who was abducted with his son and father-in-law when they were on their way to church on March 14. Police managed to track Butler and the other two victims to a hideout in Soweto. Three South Africans and a Bulgarian suspect were arrested in connection with the incident.

Johannesburg businessman Zunaid Tayob, 33, was snatched by six men several kilometres from his Houghton home five days later, on March 19. The kidnappers demanded about R1,86-million for his release before police foiled the crime and Tayob was released unhurt. Other victims include Chinese businessman Chi-Chen Shen, an unnamed Greek business tycoon, who lives in Bedfordview on the East Rand, Canadian Jean Pierre Li Shing Tat - who was found dead - and Japanese businessman Kensuke Matsumoto.

The advanced-fee scam involves the international circulation of an appeal to businessmen requesting help to transfer over-budgeted money, while the black dollar scam involves the sale of counterfeit US dollars covered in ink.

Source: IoL

KZN farmers form vigilante group

An angry group of KZN sugar farmers frustrated by lack of police action have formed a vigilante group, effectively "taking the law into their own hands" to fight the criminals in the area. The farmers, who attended the launch-meeting armed with different kinds of firearms, unanimously agreed on Tuesday night "that we cannot afford a single farmer being killed and we have to send a clear message that we are tired of the police and we are forming a vigilante group to protect ourselves".

The 40 farmers protested that for many years they had co-operated with the police but the cases would always be thrown out of court "due to lack of sufficient evidence", even when the suspects were caught in the act."For far too long we have worked with the police but out of 10 cases not a single case was resolved. Even when we caught the suspects and called the police, they would promise to come but they never did," one farmer said. Farm owner and former councillor Manna Naidoo said their families were suffering attacks on an hourly basis. "On Saturday at 4.00am an armed robbery took place and the SAPS were called to the scene. While they were attending to that one, another report of hijacking was dispatched on our radio system. In that case the attacker's gun failed to go off and the farmer survived. "An hour later four armed men were seen breaking into a store; they were apprehended. On Saturday night my house was burgled and my safe broken with an angle grinder. Four of my priceless guns were stolen with lots of ammunition," he said.

Naidoo said last Thursday unknown men shot dead Lawrence Govender's wife. Govender was grazed by the bullet which killed his wife. He said their produce was stolen every day and the police could not cope with the spiralling crime in the north Durban area. "Now we must show with an example that we are not afraid to protect our people. We are starting patrols tonight. Even when police are not there we will fight them. When we arrest them we will take them to the kangaroo courts and what happens to them there, well we will cross that bridge when we get there," said one furious farmer with a pistol hanging on his shoulder.

Mondli Maseko, who works in Durban, took a day off from work to focus his attention on a strategy to fight criminals who repeatedly attacked them. The former Mayor of Verulam, Ramdhani Ram-barum, supported the decision of the farmers to form the vigilante group, saying it was clear that the farmers were angry and concerned about the safety of their lives. "But I want to caution you that this operation needs tight control and management and you must start planning tonight," he said. He warned that they should not go on a "killing spree" but should protect themselves because the police had shown that they had no capacity. Every farmer who spoke based his input on his personal experience of his involvement in fighting the criminals who seemed to know the movement of their victims.

KwaZulu-Natal police spokesman Director Bala Naidoo said a lot had been done to help farmers. "We launched the rural safety programme which was working very well in certain areas. And those farmers must organise themselves into a farm watch," he said.

Source: IoL

Fraud will sink us sooner than crime

With serious financial fraud exceeding South Africa's R350 billion annual gross domestic product, fraud was more likely to sink the local economy than escalating crime and violence, according to Gavin Searle, the managing director of Alexander Forbes Corporate Risk Services in KwaZulu Natal. Searle said yesterday this finding applied not only to large-scale commercial crime, where individual transactions ran into hundreds of millions of rands, but also to so-called "ordinary fraud". This too had increased dramatically, with the value of individual fraudulent transactions shooting up alarmingly. Searle's observations were based on statistics from the South African police for the first three months of 1996, 1997 and 1998.Between January and March 1996, 14 456 cases of fraud were reported valued at R734,9 million and, although this dropped by 3,1 percent to R709,4 million over the same period the following year, there was a 9,4 percent increase during the first three months of 1998 to R993,6 million. Between the first three months of 1997 and 1998, the average value per docket increased by 28 percent while the overall value of the cases reported was 40,1 percent higher.

Searle said the almost out-of-control fraud problem in South Africa had an interesting history. The value of "ordinary fraud" investigations grew from R1 billion in 1988 to R7 billion in 1991 and had increased almost exponentially every year. At the beginning of 1992, the commercial branch of the police reported 22 800 open case dockets of fraud, totalling R3,6 billion. At the same time, the Office for Serious Economic Offences (Osea) reported 35 cases, valued at around R2,3 billion. Together, these represented an increase of nearly 75 percent in the value of economic crime over the previous year. Since then the situation had deteriorated considerably. In 1996, the commercial branch reported 54 119 open cases valued at R21,1 billion, while Osea logged 33 cases on hand worth R8,5 billion.

According to the police, 42,1 percent of fraud cases came from Gauteng last year, followed by 16,3 percent from the Western Cape, 11 percent from the Eastern Cape and 7,6 percent from KwaZulu Natal. The problem many South African industrialists had discovered was that these crimes were not confined to South Africa. Syndicates with strong international links or members of powerful global syndicates were being identified. This supported warnings from investigators that this country, with its sophisticated financial systems, but overstretched policing resources, was seen as an ideal haven for money laundering.

Searle said South African companies should not feel isolated. In the United States, employees stole about $120 billion annually, with average cheque fraud amounting to $125 000 and the average bank robbery netting $3 200. It was estimated that, in 1995, cheque forgery and counterfeiting cost US business over $12,6 billion, while the combined figure for South Africa was a conservative "guesstimate" of R300 million.

Source: IoL

Sisters oppose brothers' amnesty

TWO sisters have turned against their brothers, one of whom pursued and shot dead their 79-year old father, who was also necklaced and set on fire. Ms Zodwa Cele and Ms Nkosazana Cele on Tuesday opposed the amnesty application of their brother Mr Roy Cele (40), who killed his father, Mr Amos Cele, in the late 1980s. The sisters testified at the amnesty hearing of their brothers Roy and Thulani Cele (34), who together led a group of youth in the Inanda area. Both men have applied for amnesty for the murder in December 1989 of their IFP-supporting father and of their relatives Ms Dudu Ngcobo and Mr Martin Ngcobo, who were also aligned to the organisation. The brothers were each sentenced to five years in jail for public violence and 15 years each for the murders.

The Cele sisters told the amnesty committee of the Truth and Reconciliation Commission, sitting in Durban, that their brothers used the community to settle a domestic dispute following previous conflicts with their father. They dismissed any political motive for the crime. "I pursued somebody and shot him in the bush. I think it was my father, because he was found the next day at that spot," said Roy Cele. He said his father's houses were also set alight by the groups he led.

The amnesty committee, led by Judge Sisi Khampepe, spent time cross-examining Cele. Zodwa Cele told the committee that the two other victims were related to Thulani and Roy, the leaders of the vigilante group. She said they had come from Umlazi to Inanda for Christmas and not for political activities. Trouble started when Martin Ngcobo was found dead at a bus stop. A group of people then came from Umlazi to Thulani and Roy's house to inquire about the murder and the arm missing from the body.

Evidence that a group of people came looking for the brothers was denied by Zodwa Cele. Instead, she said the group beat her with a sjambok, assaulted her with stones and left her bleeding. "As I was running back home I saw a group of people led by Thulani Cele beating up Dudu (Ngcobo)," she said. She told of the chaos in the family when Roy led the group to his father's house. The sisters, one pregnant with twins, held their children and fled from their house. The Cele sisters said they would not like their brothers granted amnesty because they lied in their testimony.

Source: IoL

Tuesday, June 22, 1999

De Kock: told to 'make a plan'

Former security police major Jan Potgieter conceded that former Vlakplaas commander Eugene de Kock may have interpreted something he had said as an order to kill askari Johannes Mabotha. "Something had to have happened in that telephone discussion to make De Kock prepare a murder scene," lawyer Wim Cornelius told Potgieter at the Truth and Reconciliation Commission (TRC) in Pretoria on Tuesday."I agree," Potgieter said.

On Monday, Potgieter denied that he had asked De Kock to kill Mabotha in 1989. He said he had asked De Kock to keep Mabotha safe at Vlakplaas because he would have been a witness against Winnie Madikizela-Mandela in a possible high treason case.De Kock told the TRC's amnesty committee earlier this month that Potgieter had asked him to "make a plan" with Mabotha to end his alleged involvement in police killings.

De Kock is seeking amnesty for killing Mabotha at Penge Mine near Burgersfort in Mpumalanga in 1989. Mabotha's body was blown up with explosives after De Kock shot him twice in the heart. Potgieter, who is not seeking amnesty for the incident, was earlier this month subpoenaed by the TRC to testify, because there were discrepancies between his and De Kock's evidence about Mabotha's death.

Mabotha, a former Vlakplaas askari, was arrested at Marble Hall in February 1989 after he disappeared from Vlakplaas and joined Madikizela-Mandela's Mandela United Football Club. Potgieter interrogated him for about six months on his involvement with Madikizela-Mandela. When it was time for Mabotha to be released, Potgieter phoned De Kock and asked him to house Mabotha at Vlakplaas as his life might have been in danger - the ANC knew he had been interrogated.

Yesterday, Potgieter said he could not remember if he had used Mabotha's name when he spoke to De Kock, and might have referred to the "Marble Hall askari". He said he could not remember exactly what he had said about Mabotha, but if he had told De Kock to "make a plan", De Kock could have misinterpreted the meaning. Potgieter said he handed Mabotha over to security members under the impression that he was going to Vlakplaas. Later that day Mabotha was shot dead. Potgieter had bought Mabotha a train ticket to Pietersburg so that he could go there if he no longer wanted to stay at Vlakplaas. Mabotha would have contacted him from Pietersburg, where Mabotha's family lived, and alternative arrangements would have been made for his safekeeping, Potgieter said. He said he never told De Kock about the ticket, or Mabotha being a witness against Madikizela-Mandela.

De Kock earlier told the amnesty committee he would never have killed Mabotha if he had known that the askari was to be a witness against Madikizela-Mandela. He said it would have been "suitable" if Madikizela-Mandela was prosecuted.

Source: IoL

Monday, June 21, 1999

Secret Service to open SA office

South Africa has become the country of choice of Nigerian fraudsters who are using it increasingly as a base for their international scams, the United States Secret Service says. It is believed this is one of the reasons for the opening in Pretoria next month of a US Secret Service office that will investigate frauds and counterfeiting.

Tom Johnston, a supervisory special agent from Atlanta, US, said in a telephone interview yesterday that the "South African connection" was a headache for the US government. "In the past two years we have seen the main operations moving from Nigeria to other countries, including South Africa," he said. The Secret Service Field Office established a number of task forces eight years ago to tackle Nigerian fraud - "you name it and they are involved in it to some extent".

Johnston said Nigerians commonly were not involved in violent crimes. He was surprised that they might be linked to the kidnapping of a Japanese businessman in the Durban area. "This isn't their usual modus operandi." The Secret Service was liaising with South African law enforcement agencies, Johnston said. "When our office opens (in Pretoria), our agents will work with the South African police on all fraud matters."

Source: IoL

US Secret Service to open SA office

South Africa has become the country of choice of Nigerian fraudsters who are using it increasingly as a base for their international scams, the United States Secret Service says. It is believed this is one of the reasons for the opening in Pretoria next month of a US Secret Service office that will investigate frauds and counterfeiting.

Tom Johnston, a supervisory special agent from Atlanta, US, said in a telephone interview yesterday that the "South African connection" was a headache for the US government. "In the past two years we have seen the main operations moving from Nigeria to other countries, including South Africa," he said. The Secret Service Field Office established a number of task forces eight years ago to tackle Nigerian fraud - "you name it and they are involved in it to some extent". Johnston said Nigerians commonly were not involved in violent crimes. He was surprised that they might be linked to the kidnapping of a Japanese businessman in the Durban area. "This isn't their usual modus operandi."

The Secret Service was liaising with South African law enforcement agencies, Johnston said. "When our office opens (in Pretoria), our agents will work with the South African police on all fraud matters."

Source: IoL

Saturday, June 19, 1999

South African Names Cabinet: Familiar Faces in New Posts

South Africa's new President, Thabo Mbeki, today named Jacob Zuma his deputy. The announcement ended speculation that Mangosuthu Buthelezi, the fiery leader of the Zulu Inkatha Freedom Party, would get the post in a move intended to strengthen peace between him and the African National Congress. Mr. Buthelezi remains the Home Affairs Minister. Mr. Zuma, the deputy leader of the African National Congress and a close ally of Mr. Mbeki, is considered to have been a key player in making inroads into the Zulu party's traditional base of support base.

In naming his Cabinet, President Mbeki kept key economic ministers in place, including Trevor Manuel as Finance Minister and Alex Erwin as Trade and Industry Minister, decisions that were widely applauded by the business community. Most of his Cabinet members served in President Nelson Mandela's Cabinet, although many will have new posts. Mr. Mbeki said he was ''not visualizing any major changes in policy.'' He also noted that the number of women had doubled, to 8, out of 29 posts. On the whole Mr. Mbeki's choices were applauded for rewarding competence and maintaining stability. ''The positive thing here is the continuity,'' said Sean Jacobs, a political analyst with the Institute for Democracy in South Africa. ''And he did get rid of a lot of dead wood.''

A new post, Special Minister in the President's Office, went to Essop Pahad, a friend from Mr. Mbeki's days as a student exile in England. Mr. Pahad's appointment was in line with Mr. Mbeki's desire to strengthen the presidency. In the last few weeks, he has announced that he would absorb the Deputy President's staff into his own office and assume the power to appoint the top administrators in the ministries.

In 1994 Mr. Mandela was obliged to cobble together a multiparty Government. But Mr. Mbeki, with a firm majority, can do as he chooses. Nevertheless, he has kept three Inkatha members in his Government: Mr. Buthelezi and two deputy ministers. Mr. Mbeki at least twice brushed off questions about whether he had offered the deputy's job to Mr. Buthelezi. Mr. Buthelezi told the South African Press Association today that he had never wanted the job, but earlier this week he said he had rejected an offer.

One big surprise was the switch of assignment for Dr. Nkosazana Zuma, who is to become Minister of Foreign Affairs. Dr. Zuma, who is divorced from Mr. Zuma, is considered one of Mr. Mbeki's favorites though she has been a controversial Health Minister, taking on the tobacco and pharmaceutical industries and angering AIDS activists by refusing to finance the drug AZT for pregnant mothers infected with the virus that causes the disease.

Source: New Ypork Times

Friday, June 18, 1999

Mbeki Calls for Rebirth of South Africa

Thabo Mbeki became South Africa's second post-apartheid President today, taking over this still racially divided country from Nelson Mandela, the man who, with unerring grace, steered it through a peaceful transition out of white supremacy. Moments after Mr. Mbeki took the oath of office in Tswana, English and Afrikaans, the 80-year-old Mr. Mandela embraced his successor and then both men turned and clasped hands high over their heads as the crowd roared its approval.

In his speech, Mr. Mbeki, 56, sounded many of the themes he has become known for, promising that change would come faster now for the millions of South Africans who live in dire poverty. But he also paid tribute to the freedom fighters who came before him, including Mr. Mandela, who spent 27 years in prison for his belief that he and other black South Africans should have the right to vote. Mr. Mbeki called on all South Africans, black and white, to continue to work together for the rebirth of the country, made possible by ''the realization that we share a common destiny, regardless of the shapes of our noses.'' ''Our nights cannot but be nights of nightmares while millions of our people live in degrading poverty,'' he said. ''Sleep cannot come easily when children get permanently disabled, both physically and mentally, because of a lack of food.''

The transition from Mr. Mandela to Mr. Mbeki has lacked the giddy excitement of the 1994 election. But South Africans are reveling in its ordinariness. In 1994 many whites stocked up on canned foods or took ''strategic vacations.'' By contrast, today's ceremonies competed for attention with a soccer match and the national marathon. The inauguration ceremony, attended by hundreds of foreign dignitaries, was in some ways austere, taking only about an hour. But it was not without its glitches.

After Mr. Mbeki took the oath of office, five jets flew overhead, leaving a rainbow-colored smoke trail. Then three helicopters passed by, pulling huge South African flags. Then a Mirage fighter roared past, painted as the South African flag. When nothing further appeared, the master of ceremonies invited Mr. Mbeki to begin his speech. He protested, saying there were more planes to come. But the emcee insisted. When he was well into his address, three 747's finally thundered over, low and slow, drowning him out. The two outer planes bore messages painted under their wings. One said, ''President Thabo Mbeki.'' The other said, ''Thank you, Madiba,'' using Mr. Mandela's clan name.

Mr. Mandela, who did not speak during the ceremony, has said he is looking forward to retirement and in particular to spending more time with his grandchildren. But his wife, Graca Machel, said recently that she doubted he could sit still for long. The South Africa that Mr. Mbeki will inherit has changed a great deal in the last five years. More than 500,000 new houses were built, and electricity, telephone lines and water taps have been installed in millions of homes. But some critics have said that Mr. Mandela was more of a hero figure, focusing on reconciliation, than an administrator, focusing on rebuilding a country that systematically kept the black majority in poverty. The country is still plagued by high crime, joblessness, poor schools and a climbing AIDS rate. Nor has racial reconciliation been easy. Some South Africans believe that the country is more polarized then ever, as whites see their privileges diminishing and blacks say change is not coming fast enough for them.

Mr. Mbeki, who has an economics degree from Sussex University in England, has made it clear that he will turn his attention to uplifting the poor. He is seen as an able administrator -- far less forgiving than Mr. Mandela, who some said tended to console ministers who had failed in a job rather than tell them off.

The ceremony today did not include the swearing-in of a deputy president, as it did in 1994, because one has not been chosen. The job appears to have been offered to the leader of the Zulu-nationalist Inkatha Freedom Party, Chief Mangosuthu Buthelezi. The move is intended to promote peace between Inkatha and the governing African National Congress. But Chief Buthelezi is said to be unhappy with changes that Mr. Mbeki announced last week, which will greatly reduce the powers of the job. Negotiations are continuing. South Africans are also waiting to see whom Mr. Mbeki will include in his Cabinet, which he is expected to announce on Thursday. While Mr. Mandela's Cabinet was a carefully chosen quilt of diverse South Africans, meant to unify a country that has 11 languages and an often violent history, Mr. Mbeki has said he will put far more emphasis on competence.

Today's ceremonies were not without controversy. Statues of apartheid-era heroes that are scattered on the lawn of the Union Building, where the ceremonies were held, were draped in green sackcloth. Officials have given various reasons, at one point saying the statues were being hidden so as not to detract from the ''ecstasy'' of the occasion. The subject has kept radio talk shows in business for days, with callers either applauding the idea or saying that the country should never forget its history. There has also been some debate about the $8 million price tag for the ceremony and free concert lasting all afternoon and into the night on the lawn in front of the buildings. ''They shouldn't have spent the money,'' said Ernest Nhlapo, 17, who nevertheless was in attendance. ''They should build homes and create more jobs.'' But his friend Claudio Bowker, 16, disagreed. ''We deserve it,'' he said. ''This doesn't happen often. It's only the second time we had such a ceremony.'' Samson Malaka, 24, a student at the University of Pretoria, said the money had been well spent because the world was watching, so it was good marketing. ''It's an occasion of great magnitude,'' he said. ''We should portray to the world that we are capable of such an occasion.''

Almost the entire celebratory crowd on the Union Building lawn was black, which troubled Stanley Sidimela, 25, a welfare worker there. ''We want to live with the whites, Indians and Coloreds, but to our surprise they are not appreciating the new Government,'' he said. ''We don't know how to draw them in so we can celebrate with them. They built these buildings, which helped us. But we don't like their leaving the country -- we want to share its wealth together.'' Part of the reason for the crowd's makeup was the music, which included South Africa's best jazz, gospel, kwaito and township jive acts, including Hugh Masekela, Brenda Fassie, Rebecca Malope, Bonga'maffin and Boom Shaka. As part of Mr. Mbeki's African Renaissance theme, the organizers also invited many of Africa's best musicians, like Angelique Kidjo and Papa Wemba. Local acts that draw white audiences, like Springbok Nude Girls or Nico Carstens, were not on the stage.

A group of young women, all studying to be paralegals at the Pretoria Technikon, led the center of the crowd in a circular dance. ''We're here to party and to meet people,'' said Thandi Nkomo, 18, ''But I liked Mbeki's speech. It was short, but it had meaning.'' Mathabo Kgolumo, 21, said seeing the bookish new President speak ''gives us self-confidence, and it also improves our vocabulary.''

The only icon that was more ubiquitous in the crowd than African National Congress T-shirts was a pink sticker saying, ''Safe Sex Save Lives -- Use a Condom.'' Tina Magongwa and Gladys Mamosadi of the Mohau Children's Care Center were slapping the stickers as fast as they could on anyone who walked by. South Africa has the world's fastest-growing AIDS epidemic, largely because it was fatally slow to begin serious AIDS education programs. ''Almost no one says no,'' Mrs. Magongwa, 38, said. '''A few say, 'No, don't give me that; I will get AIDS from it,' but they are just ignorant.'' The women were also handing out condoms -- just about the only thing being given out free at the concert.

Source: New York Times

Wednesday, June 9, 1999

In South Africa, Winner Almost Takes All

Final election results in South Africa showed today that the ruling African National Congress was returned to power with even more votes than it won in 1994. But it fell just one seat short of a two-thirds majority in Parliament. Five days after the country held its second post-apartheid elections, its Independent Election Commission announced that it had finished counting and verifying the nearly 16 million votes cast last Wednesday.

According to commission figures, the party won 266 of Parliament's 400 seats. The liberal Democratic Party had the next-highest total, with 38 seats, followed by the Zulu-nationalist Inkatha Freedom Party, with 34 seats, and the Afrikaner-led New National Party, with 28 seats. The newly formed United Democratic Movement, headed by Bantu Holomisa, a former A.N.C. official who was ejected from the party for insubordination, got 14 seats. All told, 13 parties are to have seats in South Africa's next Parliament, about twice as many as in 1994, though they will have 14 fewer seats between them.

At the ceremony announcing the final count, South Africa's next President, Thabo Mbeki, pledged that democracy was ''here to stay'' in South Africa. Mr. Mbeki, 56, currently Deputy President, who was the A.N.C.'s only candidate for President, borrowed from Yeats, saying: ''There were many in our country and elsewhere who thought that things would fall apart, that the center could not hold.'' But Mr. Mbeki, who is expected to take office on June 16, added that it did hold. ''It has held in favor of democracy and of the people of South Africa,'' he said.

African National Congress officials started off the campaign season saying they wanted a two-thirds majority so they could consider changing some aspects of the Constitution. But when opposition parties focused their campaigns on warning the electorate of the A.N.C.'s plans, the party's officials began downplaying the goal. In recent weeks, Mr. Mbeki has dismissed its importance, saying he had no plans to change the Constitution. Some political analysts said that the failure to win two-thirds of the Parliament's seats might be a blessing in disguise for the party. ''They are saved from the internal struggles that might have cropped up if they had the two-thirds majority,'' said Shaun Mackay, a researcher with the nonprofit Center for Policy Studies.

The A.N.C.'s victory was overwhelming, not only in the national election, but in the nine provincial elections as well. It failed to win a clear majority in only two provinces, the Western Cape, which includes Cape Town, and KwaZulu/Natal, which includes Durban and is the heartland of the Inkatha Freedom Party. Negotiations over coalitions between various parties have already begun. Several newspapers have reported that the A.N.C. is offering Inkatha's leader, Chief Mangosuthu Buthelezi, the job of Deputy President in exchange for control over who will be the premier of the KwaZulu/Natal province.

Mr. Mbeki seemed to give his strongest public signal yet that he would appoint Mr. Buthelezi in his Cabinet to be announced next week. He called Mr. Buthelezi up to the stage from where he was sitting with his Inkatha colleagues, saying jokingly, ''I want to take him out of the I.F.P. and put him in government.'' According to the South African Press Association, Mr. Buthelezi tonight denied that he had been offered the deputy position. On whether he would accept the post if it was offered, he replied: ''That is like saying if you were offered a box of chocolates, would you eat them?''

The African National Congress and Inkatha have been rivals for more than a decade. Before the 1994 elections more than 10,000 people died in fighting between the two sides. But in recent years, the two parties have been trying to work together and Mr. Buthelezi has filled in as President whenever President Nelson Mandela and Mr. Mbeki were out of the country at the same time. Although some areas of Kwazulu/ Natal were tense during the election campaign, violence was minimal.

Source: New Ypork Times

Sunday, June 6, 1999

Film Violence: No Hollywood Defense

For years, Hollywood moguls and studio chiefs have sought to use their influence, voices and money for numerous political and social causes, from apartheid, AIDS and migrant farm workers to Democratic candidates for state and national office.

But the one issue over which the Hollywood hierarchy has direct control and responsibility -- violence in films -- has left industry executives uncharacteristically silent. In fact, the moguls and studio chiefs whose violent films are even more popular abroad than in the United States, seem like a herd of deer caught in the headlights of Washington's focus.

Left unspoken is a tenet that Hollywood executives are almost reluctant to acknowledge: violence sells.

In the aftermath of the killings at a Colorado high school in April, angry criticism among lawmakers in Washington has included accusations of Hollywood's irresponsibility and demands for controls over the marketing practices of the film, recording and video game industries.

President Clinton, who has raised tens of millions of dollars for the Democratic Party among the Hollywood elite, unexpectedly announced on Tuesday that he had asked the Justice Department and the Federal Trade Commission to study whether the entertainment industry was implicitly luring children to watch violent films, listen to sexually explicit music lyrics and play video games that depict mayhem and murder.

Producers and studio executives here insist that Hollywood is an easy target, especially for lawmakers who are loath to take on the gun lobby. Moreover, executives say, holding the entertainment industry responsible for youth violence -- especially after the high school killings that took 15 lives in Littleton, Colo. -- is not just unfair but wrong.

''When people become outraged, they look for someone to blame it on,'' said Jack Valenti, chairman of the Motion Picture Association of America, the studio's lobbying arm, in Washington. ''And movies, being so high-profile, become an inviting target.''

But this hardly explains the resolute, and surprising, silence of most top executives in town. Mr. Clinton's most vocal supporters in Hollywood, David Geffen, Jeffrey Katzenberg and Steven Spielberg, who run Dreamworks, declined to talk about violence. A spokeswoman at Warner Brothers, which has produced films like Oliver Stone's ''Natural Born Killers,'' with its brutal and horrific murders, and the jokey but violent ''Lethal Weapon'' series, said Mr. Valenti would handle all questions about violence.

Similarly, executives at several other major studios said, through associates, that they would not discuss the issue.

One top producer, who makes his share of violent films and who spoke on the condition of anonymity, said simply: ''By going after the movie business, it's like taking a high-powered rifle into a field and shooting a cow. The cow is standing there. It's the easiest target in the world. It's as simple as that. What do we do? We make movies. We make excitement. We don't make movies to create killers.''

Although their underlings are silent, corporate titans like Time Warner's chief executive, Gerald Levin, and Seagram's chief executive, Edgar Bronfman Jr., have briefly spoken out and accused Washington of trying to use Hollywood as a scapegoat, and indicated that the entertainment industry's output is not an important factor in the violent behavior of children.

Mr. Levin, whose conglomerate includes Warner Brothers and the WB network, criticized the political opportunism and moral arrogance of Washington for faulting Hollywood but failing to deal in any major way with the gun issue. And Mr. Bronfman, who owns Universal Studios, has accused Washington of finger-pointing and chest-pounding on violence issues.

But, within Hollywood itself, the issue among those who actually green-light films seems more complicated. For one, the movie business, and perhaps the nation itself, has an ambivalent attitude toward violent films in contrast to movies that deal with sexual issues. It is commonly known in Hollywood, for example, that movies dealing with sex have a far more difficult time with the the Motion Picture Association's ratings board than those that are extremely violent.

Just recently the creators of ''American Pie,'' a light-hearted comedy that opens next month, about Midwestern teen-agers struggling with sex, were compelled to go four times before the Motion Picture Association's rating board to finally get an R-rating as opposed to a prohibitive NC-17, which would have effectively killed the movie commercially.

By contrast, the ratings board fails to raise substantive questions about extremely violent films like ''Natural Born Killers'' and ''The Basketball Diaries'' and, more recently, ''Pulp Fiction,'' ''Con Air,'' ''Payback,'' ''8 MM,'' ''Scream'' and numerous others. All were awarded R-ratings.

Why are films dealing with sex given more rigorous treatment by the ratings board than those that are violent?

''We're dealing with subjectivity here,'' Mr. Valenti said. ''Sex is easier to define. There are only so many ways to couple. Language is easier to define, too. But what is too much violence? The ratings board has to decide. Is 'Schindler's List' too violent? Is 'Saving Private Ryan' too violent? What about 'The Wild Bunch'? There are so many ways that violence can be committed.''

But Irwin Winkler, a veteran producer of films like ''Rocky'' and the four other ''Rocky'' movies, and classics like ''Raging Bull'', ''The Right Stuff'' and ''Goodfellas'' , said pointedly that the ratings system had failed to deal with the violence issue.

''I don't understand the ratings board,'' he said. ''If you cut off a woman's breast, it's probably not as terrible as showing her nipple. They're very free about violence and puritanical about sex.''

So far television has responded a bit to Washington's accusations. At the WB network, executives recently pulled the series finale of ''Buffy, the Vampire Slayer,'' because it dealt with a high school graduation ceremony that exploded into violence. The episode will be shown later this summer.

At the same time, CBS decided not to pick up ''Falcone,'' a Mafia series, for its fall lineup but held out the possibility that it could be shown later in the year. Leslie Moonves, the CBS network president, said: ''We felt a responsibility not to put it on now. It just didn't feel right.'' The network has, however, several action shows with violence on the air.

What impact the current debate will have in Hollywood is, of course, unclear. No one expects studios to stop making violent films as long as many of them are so successful, especially overseas. (The recent ''Lethal Weapon 4,'' for example, took in $130 million at the domestic box office, barely making back its cost. It also took in $155 million abroad.)

''I do sense that there is an unusual sensitivity now to this issue -- and I hope it's more than lip service,'' said Steve Tisch, a producer of movies like ''Forrest Gump'' and ''American History X.''

Mr. Winkler echoed Mr. Tisch. ''I think people are taking it seriously now, partly because they're being attacked.'' But he added, ''I don't think people took it seriously in the past.''

Source: New York Times

Saturday, June 5, 1999

African National Congress Re-elected in Landslide

The African National Congress won a second term today in a landslide victory that will probably give South Africa's next President, Thabo Mbeki, control of more than two-thirds of Parliament. The party won even more votes than it did five years ago, when it first swept to power in South Africa's historic apartheid-ending election with just under 63 percent of the ballot. Late evening returns suggested the A.N.C. may have won more than 65 percent this time, and analysts with the state-owned television were predicting the final share would be 67 percent.

Mr. Mbeki, the party's only candidate to replace President Nelson Mandela when he retires on June 16, claimed victory early in the afternoon, promising to build a multiracial society and to speed the pace of change. ''In their millions, and without equivocation, without hesitation, the people of South Africa have renewed the mandate of the A.N.C. to run this country,'' a serious Mr. Mbeki told hundreds of supporters who danced and ululated in front of him at the party's headquarters here. He promised to govern with humility and ''a deep sense of responsibility'' and to insure that ''we act together to build a South Africa which truly belongs to all who live in it, both black and white.''

Throughout the campaign the 80-year-old Mr. Mandela has taken a back seat to the reserved Mr. Mbeki. Though Mr. Mbeki has none of Mr. Mandela's ease with people, he has surprised many analysts by throwing himself into the handshaking and baby-kissing, sometimes even shedding the suits he favors for sports shirts. Mr. Mandela went on vacation after casting his vote on Wednesday and was not present when Mr. Mbeki made his speech today. In fact, the victory rally seemed to confirm a new era, with the focus completely on Mr. Mbeki. Supporters chanted his name, and posters with his picture filled the backdrop.

Mr. Mbeki referred to his predecessor, who served 27 years in prison for believing that all South Africans should have equal rights, only at the end of his speech as he thanked him and other A.N.C. officials for their election effort. Despite the end of South Africa's apartheid system in 1994, the country remains deeply divided along racial lines, with most of the country's wealth still in white hands. The elections only highlighted the divisions, as most of the country's blacks -- about 77 percent of the population -- supported the A.N.C. while most of the country's white, mixed-race and Indian citizens supported white-led parties. The African National Congress had set a two-thirds share of Parliament as its goal, but that deepened fears in the minority communities. With such a majority the party would have the power to change some aspects of the Constitution, though in recent weeks Mr. Mbeki has said repeatedly that he had no intention of doing so.

Mr. Mbeki, 56, has been a powerful behind-the-scenes force here. A British-educated economist, he is considered an able administrator and one of the architects of the country's conservative economic policies. Mr. Mandela has said for years now that Mr. Mbeki has been effectively running the country on a day to day basis in his role as Deputy President. Many supporters of the A.N.C. believe that he will be better able to govern with more rigor than Mr. Mandela, who is sometimes seen here as too soft. But his critics worry that he is too sensitive to criticism, and they point out that his political rivals have found themselves quickly sidelined.

The country that Mr. Mbeki will inherit has already changed a great deal since apartheid ended. In those five years, it has adopted one of the world's most liberal Constitutions and passed more than 500 laws revamping the legal system, which had classified everyone by race and prevented nonwhites from voting. Much has been done to improve living conditions as well. More than 500,000 houses have been built and millions of South African now have electricity, telephones and running water, which they did not have before. But the country is beset by crime and an unemployment rate that approaches 40 percent. Many of those who have new houses, water and electricity are unable to pay for their services. The education system is in shambles and the country has one of the fastest growing AIDS rates in the world. Corruption and incompetence, particularly in provincial governments, are major issues.

Polls indicated that support for the A.N.C. had dipped in late 1998 by about 10 percentage points. But election results suggest that the party was able to recapture disillusioned supporters by evoking its history as a liberation movement and casting the next five years as a continuation of that struggle. ''We lived with apartheid for 40 years,'' said Themba Ndlovu, 27, who lives in Soweto and sometimes gets work on construction sites. ''The A.N.C. needs more than five to make things right.''

Mr. Mbeki also stayed far above daily political squabbles, managing to look presidential wherever he went. He rarely asked for votes, choosing instead to highlight the party's accomplishments by visiting successful projects. Some analysts had predicted widespread voter apathy, but South Africans began lining up to vote on Wednesday even before the sun was up, and some voting stations were still open this morning to accommodate voters who had been on line since 9 P.M. the night before. The election commission was still counting votes late into the evening, slowed by some computer problems. But even before the final results were available, some trends seemed discernable.

The New National Party, whose predecessor ruled during the four decades of apartheid, was in danger of losing its status as the largest opposition party, with only about 8 percent of the votes. Unfamiliar with the role of an opposition party, it has been largely ineffective in Parliament and many of its voters have turned to the once tiny liberal Democratic Party.

The Democratic Party won less than 2 percent of the vote last time and had only 7 members in Parliament, but they were vocal and effective critics of the A.N.C. and, judging by this evening's returns, seemed to be winning a 10 percent share this time. ''Minorities have been saying, 'Who is going to protect their interests?' '' said Shaun Mackay, a researcher with the Institute for Race Relations. ''And the Democratic Party has come out on top as the one that can lead in this area.'' But the battle between the two parties has been bitter, with the leader of the New National Party, Martinus van Schalkwyk, accusing the Democratic Party of exploiting racial fears with its ''Fight Back'' campaign slogan. Today, Mr. Van Schalkwyk said he was disappointed in his showing, adding that he had ''paid the price'' for talking about cooperation rather than opposition. Tony Leon, the head of the Democrats, did not hesitate to claim victory. ''I don't think any party has suffered as official meltdown'' like the New National Party, he said. ''They were pretty hopeless as a Government and they got their just deserts.''

The Zulu-nationalist Inkatha Freedom Party, a long-time rival of the African National Congress, seemed to be doing about as well as in 1994, with 8 percent. This was something of a surprise, because pollsters had predicted the party's support would shrink by half. Apparently the pollsters overlooked the strength of Inkatha's support among rural voters.

The next President of South Africa, Thabo Mbeki, celebrated yesterday.

Source: New York Times